CJEU (AG) ¦ Advocate General Allows Organisational Checks in Crypto AML Registration

CJEU (AG) ¦ Advocate General Allows Organisational Checks in Crypto AML Registration

Advocate General: crypto registration under the AML Directive can include an organisational check

A supervisor registering crypto exchange and custodian wallet providers under Article 47 of the fourth AML Directive may ask for evidence of sound and controlled business organisation and may refuse registration if it is not convinced the information is accurate and complete. Advocate General Richard de la Tour proposes this in the Opinion of 19 November 2026 in Case C-415/25 De Nederlandsche Bank and Others, a reference from the Dutch College van Beroep voor het bedrijfsleven, the appeal court for economic administrative law. On that reading, the “registration” duty for virtual currency providers comes close to a licensing check, justified by minimum harmonisation and the preventive purpose of the Directive.

Note

The Opinion of an Advocate General is not binding on the Court of Justice. The judgment in Case C-415/25 is still pending. The Opinion is currently available only as a provisional French edition.

A fee dispute that turned into a question about gatekeeping

The case was brought by eleven Dutch providers of exchange services between virtual and fiat currencies and of custodian wallet services. Since 21 May 2020 these firms have fallen under the Dutch AML/CFT act, the Wet ter voorkoming van witwassen en financieren van terrorisme (Wwft), with De Nederlandsche Bank (DNB) as their supervisor. Ten of them registered with DNB in 2020 and one in 2021, each paying 5,000 euros for the handling of the application, a fee none of them challenged.

The dispute concerned the ongoing supervision costs DNB later charged. For 2020 the amounts ranged from 3,284 to 4,776 euros per provider; for 2021 they ranged from 4,299 to 423,364 euros. In the Netherlands, registration costs are part of those ongoing supervision costs. The Rotterdam district court upheld the 2020 charges but annulled those for 2021. In its view, by requiring applicants to submit whatever information DNB considered necessary and by having DNB carry out a thorough upfront review of Wwft compliance, the Dutch legislature had turned the EU registration duty into a licensing requirement that went beyond the Directive. Without a lawful basis for that review, the providers could neither be required to submit the data nor be charged for its assessment. Both DNB and the providers appealed, and the appeal court referred the question to Luxembourg.

Bastian Schwind-Wagner
Bastian Schwind-Wagner

"The Advocate General reads the word registration the way supervisors have long applied it in practice: a provider that cannot show a working AML/CFT framework should not be allowed to start trading. That fits the preventive logic of the Directive, because a crypto exchange can move illicit funds from its first day, long before any ex post inspection arrives.

For firms the lesson reaches beyond crypto and beyond the now-closed Article 47 regime. Whatever the label on the entry procedure, the application file is judged on whether the risk assessment, CDD, sanctions screening and monitoring documents are complete and hold together, and a thin or inconsistent file can keep a firm out of the market."

What Dutch law asks for at registration

Under Article 23c of the Wwft, an application for registration consists of information set by general administrative rules, which may cover factual data and data on compliance with the Wwft and the Sanctions Act 1977. Article 23d obliges DNB to refuse registration where that information is incomplete or where, after verification, DNB is not convinced it is accurate. The implementing regulation lists, among other items, the organisation of the business with a view to sound and controlled operations under Article 23j of the Wwft, and any other information DNB considers necessary for the registration.

DNB’s registration form turns this into a concrete document list. On controlled business operations, applicants must provide the job descriptions and independence safeguards of the compliance and audit functions, a procedure for reporting Wwft breaches, the outsourcing policy and the relevant outsourcing contracts, and a training policy. On sound business operations, they must submit a systematic integrity risk analysis, an integrity policy, a conflicts of interest policy and procedure, a customer due diligence policy and procedure, a sanctions screening policy and procedure, and a transaction monitoring and unusual transaction reporting policy and procedure. Taken together, that is the firm’s complete AML/CFT control framework, and DNB reviews it before the firm may start operating.

The question referred

The appeal court asked whether Article 47 of Directive 2015/849, as amended by Directive (EU) 2018/843, precludes a Member State from requiring a crypto service provider, at registration, to provide information on its organisation from the point of view of sound and controlled operations, so that it can meet national requirements, and from refusing registration where the supervisor is not convinced, on that basis, that the provider can meet them. The referring court noted that the Directive says neither what information a supervisor may request in a registration procedure nor whether registration may be refused for incomplete or doubtful information.

The providers argued that the EU legislature had deliberately chosen registration, not authorisation. The Commission’s 2016 proposal had offered Member States a choice between the two, as for currency exchange offices and trust or company service providers, but the final text kept only registration for crypto providers. Recital 9 of Directive 2018/843, they said, limited the scheme to identification, suspicious activity reporting and fit and proper checks on managers and beneficial owners. Registration in its ordinary sense means entry in a register, and a stricter authorisation regime only arrived with the Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (EU) 2023/1114. DNB countered that the Directive is minimum harmonisation, that Article 47 leaves the content of registration open, and that being unable to address deficiencies at the door would let providers without adequate organisation enter the market.

Registration is not limited to an entry in a register

The Advocate General starts with the wording. Registration can mean entering a person in a public register and assigning a number for later identification; authorisation is permission from the State needed to carry out an activity. Authorisation does not necessarily involve a public register, and registration may well require prior checks. On a literal reading, the concept of registration therefore does not exclude a preliminary review of the conditions for being registered.

On the legislative history, the Advocate General accepts that the text changed during negotiations, but rejects the conclusion that dropping authorisation was meant to lighten the formalities. The Commission’s impact assessment shows a different concern. It weighed two options: bringing crypto providers under the AML/CFT framework or under the second Payment Services Directive. Member States overwhelmingly preferred the former, because treating crypto providers as payment service providers would have lent virtual currencies too much legitimacy and might have suggested to consumers that they were safe. The European Central Bank likewise warned against promoting virtual currencies as an alternative means of payment and recommended staying with the FATF standards. On this account, registration was chosen to avoid endorsing crypto, and it says nothing about how light the AML check at the door should be.

Minimum harmonisation and the supervisor’s toolkit

The second contextual argument rests on Article 5 of Directive 2015/849, which allows Member States to adopt or retain stricter provisions to prevent money laundering and terrorist financing, within the limits of EU law. Article 48 adds that competent authorities must monitor compliance effectively and have adequate powers, including the power to compel the production of any information relevant to monitoring compliance. Together, these provisions leave Member States room to require additional information at registration, provided it serves the fight against money laundering and terrorist financing.

In the Advocate General’s assessment, information on sound and controlled business organisation is precisely the kind of measure that strengthens that fight, all the more because virtual currencies carry a high level of risk. The Directive’s provisions are preventive and risk-based. The EU legislature treated crypto providers as gatekeepers of financial market integrity because the anonymity of virtual currencies combined with the speed of transactions makes them attractive for criminal use. Drawing on the Court’s case-law, including Lietuvos bankas (C-671/23) and Rodl & Partner (C-562/20), the Advocate General finds that the Dutch scheme is suitable for its preventive aim because it helps reduce the risk of money laundering and terrorist financing. Without a prior check, illicit transactions could run through a provider before any ex post supervision was possible.

The obligation therefore appears appropriate and necessary, provided the referring court verifies that DNB applies it in line with proportionality, legality, legal certainty and non-discrimination. The Advocate General also notes that the referring court did not ask about the level of the supervision fees or their possible disproportion, only about the registration procedure. The providers themselves pointed out that the 5,000 euro registration fee sat between those charged at the time in France and Belgium (8,000 euros) and Denmark (1,000 euros).

Refusal turns on accuracy and completeness

On the grounds for refusal, the Advocate General corrects the premise of the question. Article 23d of the Wwft does not require DNB to be convinced that the provider can comply with its legal obligations. It allows refusal where DNB is not convinced that the information provided, in particular on the organisation of the business, is accurate and complete. Because the grounds for refusal are set out in the law, arbitrary decisions are excluded.

DNB may therefore check the consistency of the planned management policies and ask for further material where it has doubts, so that risk management policies and the fit and proper standing of managers and shareholders are in place from the outset. Since a refusal can be challenged in court, the Advocate General considers the providers’ rights adequately protected. The proposed answer is that Article 47 does not preclude a registration duty that involves providing information on sound and controlled business organisation, so that the provider can meet national requirements after registration, nor a refusal where the supervisor is not convinced the information is accurate and complete.

What it means for crypto providers, supervisors and Luxembourg

For crypto firms, the Article 47 registration regime belongs to the past. Article 38(7) of the Transfer of Funds Regulation (EU) 2023/1113 removed crypto providers from it, and crypto-asset service providers now need a MiCA authorisation that already requires information on governance and internal controls. The Opinion is still relevant, because the answer decides whether Member States lawfully ran a demanding pre-entry review during the registration years, and with it whether supervisory costs charged for that period stand. Several Member States, Luxembourg among them with its own CSSF registration for virtual asset service providers, operated registration regimes in that period, and firms that contested fees or refusals will read the Opinion closely.

The broader point concerns how supervisors may use minimum harmonisation. If the Court follows the Advocate General, a “registration” label in an EU AML instrument does not stop a Member State from asking for a complete AML/CFT control framework at entry: risk assessment, CDD, sanctions screening, transaction monitoring and reporting, compliance and audit functions, and training. That reasoning may carry over to other registered sectors and to how national authorities read their gatekeeping powers alongside the new AML Regulation and the AMLA framework. For firms entering a regulated sector, a registration application is judged on the quality and coherence of the documented AML/CFT framework, and a file that is incomplete or does not hold together can keep a firm out of the market.

The information in this article is of a general nature and is provided for informational purposes only. If you need legal advice for your individual situation, you should seek the advice of a qualified lawyer.
Did you find any mistakes? Would you like to provide feedback? If so, please contact us!
Dive deeper
  • CURIA ¦ Case C-415/25 De Nederlandsche Bank and Others, Opinion of Advocate General Richard de la Tour of 19 November 2026 ¦ Link
Bastian Schwind-Wagner
Bastian Schwind-Wagner Bastian is a recognized expert in anti-money laundering (AML), countering the financing of terrorism (CFT), compliance, data protection, risk management, and whistleblowing. He has worked for fund management companies for more than 24 years, where he has held senior positions in these areas.